Oodoc change de nom : découvrez tousLesDocs

X

Accéder à ce doc

Résumé du document
  ACCÉDER à ce doc

I was really interested in studying this subject as it is never really studied in France where some aspects of the French Revolution still remain taboo or are often viewed in the same way, according to the ?politically correct?. As a matter of fact, most history books on the Revolution (for high school for instance) only mention briefly the trial followed by the death of Louis 16, as if it was an obvious consequence of the revolutionary work, and that it happened in a very simple way. However, the truth is not that simple. Firstly, after he fled to Varenne, the new National Convention had to decide if the King was to be judged. Secondly, the Convention, opposing Jacobins against the Girondins, debated on the relevance of the condemnation of Louis XVI, who was executed against a lot of protestations. Finally, we will see if the opponents were right to fear the condemnation of the king, regarding the longer term consequences that Louis XVI's death had for France.

Extraits

[...] Expressing fears that the king’s execution might trigger civil war and inflame Europe against France, they began to argue that the Convention’s decision needed to be ratified by the country at large in primary assemblies. On 14 January, the deputies voted the guilt of the king and rejected roughly a two-thirds majority the appel au people[26]. The condemnation symbolizes the new equality of kings and citizens and their mutual subjection to the community as a whole. But is the trial morally justified ? It seems to do a specific injustice to the king, who maybe did not know that his actions were criminal. [...]


[...] Conor Cruse O’Brien pointed out that the indictment of the king was essentially for crimes against la nation, and given the Rousseau-inspired juxtaposition between and the status of being against the nation signified being against and outside of nature[4]. Once the King is put “hors nature”, with no social or moral identity, it was tolerable to put him to death. Hi execution would not even be confused with homicide[5]. But as Jean batiste Maihle argued, Louis had been a king, had been recognized a king, and could be tried as a king. To Maihle the right to judge a king was necessary condition, inherent in the social act which placed them on the throne”. [...]


[...] But in the French case, regicide, as in rebel” (Camus), is often described as the beginning of the Terror. So both the trial and the condemnation of Louis XVI were far from easy to implement, and had serious consequences on politics and national security, as some writers feared. This complexity is never mentioned in the history courses in high schools. Since 1793, the death of Louis XVI has been a potent vehicle for political and moral reflexion, a catalyst for exploring the relationship between violence and progress, pity and justice, amnesty and vengeance. [...]


[...] Michael Walzer, Regicide and revolution, Cambridge University Press revolutionary argument”, p.49 [25]Archives Parlementaires de 1787 à 1860 (Paris, 1899) 56 : 523, p.212. Colin Jones, Great Nation” the penguin Press, London p : “Louis Capet bows out, Terror bows Michael Walzer, “Regicide and revolution”, Cambridge University Press defense of the trial and execution of louis p : [28]The Works of Joseph de Maistre, Shocken Books pp. 50–53. London Times “Execution of Louis January Susan Dunn, deaths of Louis Princeton University Press 1994 - Chapter one cult of human sacrifice” p15-36. [...]


[...] They set out to eliminate their enemies, in the words of Maximilien Robespierre, "Be my friend, or I will kill you." And "Softness to traitors will destroy us all." It can be said that the 'Terror' was instituted on September 5th 1793 and the Law of Suspects (defining the "suspected persons those who, either by their conduct or their relationships, by their remarks or by their writing, are shown to be partisans of tyranny and federalism and enemies of liberty" (Law of Suspects, 1793) passed on September 17. Watch Committees around the nation were encouraged to arrest. Civil liberties were suspended. The promises of the Declaration of the Rights of Man were forgotten. [...]

ACCÉDER à ce doc  

Informations sur le doc

Date de publication
03/04/2006
Langue
anglais
Format
Word
Type
dissertation
Nombre de pages
8 pages
Niveau
grand public
Consulté
1 fois

Informations sur l'auteur Tiphaine D. (étudiant)

Niveau
Grand public
Etude suivie
sciences...
Ecole, université
sciences po...
Note du document :
         
ACCÉDER à ce doc  
The condemnation of Louis XVI and its consequences

«I was really interested in studying this subject as it is never really studied in France where some aspects of the French Revolution still remain taboo or are often viewed in the same way, according to the ?politically correct?. As a matter of fact, ...»

Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .doc  |   8 pages   |   publié en 2006
The french urban model: history and present-day challenges

«Essay on Globalization and Environment dealing with the french urban model....»

Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .pdf  |   18 pages   |   publié en 2010
Martinez Louis, Voiron la Nationale

«Résumé de l'Ebook:...»

Littérature et Arts   |  Littérature  |   Ebooks  |   fr  |   .pdf  |   416 pages   |   publié en 2007
Law of international trade: from the medieval Lex Mercatoria to the modern Lex Mercatoria

«The history of law of International Trade is marked by the emergence of the "law of Merchant" called Lex Mercatoria during the Middle Ages but it seems to reappear today with the globalization. This Lex Mercatoria could be defined in opposition to th...»

Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .doc  |   14 pages   |   publié en 2009
La révocation de l'édit de Nantes (17 octobre 1685)

«Né en 1517 avec la publication des 95 thèses par Martin Luther, le protestantisme reste une religion minoritaire décriée par les catholiques pendant toute la durée de l'Ancien Régime. Au nom de l'adage « une foi, une loi, un roi » et des théories ab...»

Histoire et géographie   |  Histoire moderne  |   Dissertation  |   fr  |   .doc  |   8 pages   |   publié en 2014

Meilleures ventes en stratégie

Derniers docs en stratégie

Business Plan: the creation of a 4-star ecological hotel in Paris
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Étude de cas  |   en  |   .pdf  |   18 pages   |   publié en 2012
Diagnostic stratégique du groupe Crédit Agricole (2013)
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Mémoire  |   fr  |   .doc  |   51 pages   |   publié en 2014
The education system of France and China
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .doc  |   8 pages   |   publié en 2006
Chupa Chups' marketing strategy
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .doc  |   43 pages   |   publié en 2007
The development of online shopping
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Dissertation  |   en  |   .doc  |   4 pages   |   publié en 2007
Le diagnostic stratégique de l'entreprise Bricomarché
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Rapport de stage  |   fr  |   .doc  |   29 pages   |   publié en 2014
The Berliner - The excellence of European Breakfasts and Brunches
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Étude de cas  |   en  |   .doc  |   35 pages   |   publié en 2014
Le capital humain : Un déterminant de la réussite des reprises d'entreprise
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Mémoire  |   fr  |   .doc  |   30 pages   |   publié en 2014
Etude du groupe leader sur le marché français des produits biologiques : le réseau coopératif Biocoop
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Étude de cas  |   fr  |   .doc  |   43 pages   |   publié en 2014
Les bases de la stratégie
Commerce   |  Stratégie  |   Cours  |   fr  |   .pdf  |   6 pages   |   publié en 2014